Blogs

Essays by a diverse group of writers, in the United States and abroad, engaged in rethinking psychiatry. (The directory of personal stories can be found here, and initiatives here).

Group Of Happy Excited Doctors Raising Arms

In Defense of Incoherent Psychiatry

9
In JAMA Psychiatry, the authors claimed we have no way to assess outcomes, and no way to know whether outcomes are "continuing to improve."
A hand holding a toy plane with sunset light

Can’t Be Trusted: A Book Review Review

9
My book is a memoir written around the denial of my medical certificate required to fly light aircraft for mental health reasons.

Q&A: What Is Informed Consent, and What Should I Know to Help My Child?

5
My experience caused me to look into the origin of including the patient in decision-making about treatment and informed consent.
Black and white photo of a man looking sad with his fingers clinging to a chain-link fence

The Hidden Injuries of Oppression

50
Oppression is the single greatest factor contributing to human suffering. To treat it as an individual problem amounts to blaming the victim.

Listen to the Victims: Senate Holds Hearing on Guardianship

12
I have seen the exploitation wreaked by court-appointed guardians. It is up to us to use our voices for those who cannot speak out.
Hand of doctor holding many different pills

Critical Psychiatry Textbook, Chapter 7: Psychosis (Part Five)

4
Discussing the studies that have compared the different psychosis drugs, as well as the harms of adding more psychosis drugs to the regimen.
A Black man in a suit, in profile, with his head being fragmented digitally

Chronic Stress and “Mental Illness”

21
Could it be possible that what we call “mental illness” is a direct consequence of the changes that occur in the body as a result of trauma and chronic stress?
Close up photo of hands dripping water on a plant outside

To Promote Mental Health, We Must Teach It

49
When we are quick to pathologize suffering, yet do not provide the fundamentals for healthy living, it is inhumanity of the highest order.
Black and white photo of a tattoo of a whale and a wolf

Lost Poetry: Psychiatry and Creativity

8
A poem can be destroyed when psychiatry treats a poet without reverence and honor for their creativity and their diversity of mind.
Stock photo of a doctor holding money and talking on the phone

Critical Psychiatry Textbook, Chapter 7: Psychosis (Part Four)

1
How cold-turkey withdrawal is mistaken for "relapse," and how the largest drug companies have paid billions in fraud settlements related to these drugs.
Photo of a man leaping off a rock into green water

Life-Enhancing Anxiety: Key to a Revitalized World

0
We need to experience less comforting (though potentially highly rewarding) edges if we are to lead more fulfilling individual and collective lives.
A photo of hands holding wood tokens printed with a key design

Critical Psychiatry Textbook, Chapter 7: Psychosis (Part Three)

13
Peter Gøtzsche discusses the lack of evidence for benefit, and the evidence of harms, of psychosis drugs used for early intervention/first-episode psychosis.
A person outside holding a sign with the trans flag that reads "TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS"

LGBTQIA+ Peer Respites: The Personal Is Political

5
Peer respites have great value. Affinity peer respites—such as an LGBTQIA+ peer respite—may have even more.

Medically-Assisted Suicide Is Not a Win for Mental Health

11
Medically assisting someone in suiciding because they’re poor or experiencing mental or emotional distress does not value life; it shows a blatant disregard for it.
An abstract painting depicting heads in profile in various colors

Emotional Crisis Response: The Peer-Run Respite/Soteria House Approach Compared to the Conventional Approach

13
The peer respite/Soteria house model responds to emotional crisis with compassion and curiosity, rather than pathologizing.
Photo of a human skull sitting on a pile of pills against a black background

Critical Psychiatry Textbook, Chapter 7: Psychosis (Part Two)

9
Peter Gøtzsche reviews the evidence that psychosis pills substantially increase mortality.

Mad Poetry Slam!

0
Poets with lived experience with mental distress are invited to perform their poetry live at MIA's Mad Poetry Slam on Zoom on May 7th, 12PM EST.
Multiple-exposure portrait of a young woman's face with galaxy inside head

Acute Religious Experiences: Madness, Psychosis, and Religious Studies

20
It is the capacity of mad studies to advance the idea that mad is not necessarily bad. Acute Religious Experiences are always phenomenally mad, but not necessarily pathological.

Tolstoy’s Hermit: Jay Schulkin

2
Jay Schulkin, a neuroscientist and philosopher of prodigious curiosity and energy, has died at age 70 of hepatic cancer.
Photo of a pill bottle on a prescription pad

Critical Psychiatry Textbook, Chapter 7: Psychosis (Part One)

7
Psychosis pills were hailed as a great advance, but this was because they kept the patients docile and quiet, which was very popular with the staff in psychiatric wards.
Covers of both issues of JHP

Compassion and Understanding Versus Drugs and Disease: Where Does Humanistic Psychology Stand Now?

24
Authors with lived experience of extreme states present a humanistic contrast to psychiatry.
Illustration of a magnifying glass and a pill bottle on a pink background

Critical Psychiatry Textbook, Chapter 6: Psychiatric Drug Trials Are Not Reliable

7
In this blog, Gøtzsche discusses the ways in which drug trials are biased, including breaking of the double-blind and industry manipulation.
Business man protecting with umbrella against wind of papers concept

How Peer Reviewers and Editors Protected a Failed Paradigm for Psychiatric Drug Testing

10
My recent article was so threatening to the whole edifice of psychiatry that the peer reviewers and editors did what they could to kill it.
A bearded white man repeated pattern with hands in an expression of confusion

Critical Psychiatry Textbook, Chapter 5: Psychiatric Diagnoses Are Not Reliable (Part Two)

5
The screening test for depression recommended by the WHO is so poor that for every 100 screened, 36 will get a false diagnosis of depression.
Photograph of the red and blue lights on top of a police car at night

New York Can’t—or Won’t—Provide Data on New Forced Treatment Plan

4
When we requested specific numbers and data, the presenter suggested that there were so many different players, agencies, and moving parts it was hard to “make sense” of all the information.Â